Idea: Music critique club

They are already rolling! @josker has already provided a well structured review, setting the bar pretty high for further reviewers.

The first track was mine, and I’ve held off responding comprehensively until I understand the protocol for doing that (I didn’t want to clutter the thread).
Great review @josker. Thanks!! Where should I respond?


Yeah, it’s rolling here:

And I didn’t mean to set the bar too high :slight_smile: I agree it’s a bit long, but I didn’t feel like shortening it once I did it!

@cloudburst – I think you can just respond in the thread? I don’t really know, but that seems like the logical place :slight_smile: Learning as we go.

I’m going to leave comments on SC tracks rather than here. That’s what I’d prefer personally. Hope that’s cool?